Ads
First came the waffle fiasco, and now Meghan Markle has found herself entangled in another food-related drama — the now-infamous "fake cake gate." What was likely intended to be a sweet, homey moment shared with her followers on Instagram has instead sparked widespread speculation and criticism. The photo she posted featured a so-called homemade naked cake, captioned with a simple, “A very sweet treat indeed.” But instead of drawing admiration, it left viewers confused and doubtful. From its outdated aesthetic to the very real question of whether she baked it herself, the entire post has stirred more skepticism than sweetness.
Ads
The choice of a naked cake in particular feels like Meghan is stuck in a time capsule. That style peaked nearly a decade ago, back when Pinterest was dominated by rustic wedding inspiration — think mason jars, fairy lights, and burlap table runners. Today, it just feels stale, like flipping through a wedding magazine at the bottom of a clearance bin.
Ads
And let’s be honest, given her past baking flops — remember the great waffle disaster? — it’s hard to believe she miraculously became a master baker overnight. The cake’s messy layers and imprecise assembly don’t exactly scream culinary expertise. More likely, a professional baker was brought in to handle the heavy lifting, while Meghan swooped in at the end to drizzle a little honey on top, just in time for the photo op.
Ads
This wouldn't be the first time Meghan has given the impression of creating something herself when the real effort came from someone else. It’s a pattern — she likes to appear hands-on, involved, and effortlessly talented, but often it’s clear the polish is superficial. The cake photo falls right in line with that: an image carefully curated to give off a warm, homemade vibe, but ultimately lacking authenticity and substance.
Ads
Looking closer at the cake itself, the flaws are hard to ignore. The layers are uneven and slightly off-center, with the kind of haphazard assembly that screams "first try." The filling looks like it was applied with a butter knife in a hurry, and there’s an amateurish energy that simply doesn’t match the kind of aspirational lifestyle she seems to be aiming for.
Ads
If Meghan wants to position herself as a tastemaker — the kind of woman people look to for style, grace, and inspiration — she’s missing the mark. There’s no refinement, no artistry, and certainly no real baking prowess on display here.
What’s even more curious is how this post fits into a larger pattern Meghan seems to be crafting — an attempt to step into the role of the traditional, soft-focus homemaker influencer.
Ads
Picture Meghan Markle, Momfluencer Extraordinaire, complete with vintage recipes, filtered lighting, and perfectly staged kitchen chaos. It’s the kind of look that borrows heavily from the cottagecore aesthetic, full of nostalgia and Pinterest-worthy details. But while Martha Stewart perfected that blend of charm and capability, Meghan’s version feels hollow. Stewart’s cakes don’t look like they were glued together at a preschool baking class.
Ads
Even the honey drizzle — which seems like it was added just for effect — comes across as excessive. If the fruit topping the cake was truly fresh and flavorful, would it need a sticky layer of syrup to make it appealing? Or is this just another one of Meghan’s “more is more” moves — adding a flourish that sounds fancy, but doesn’t actually improve anything? She’s become known for these little touches that feel more performative than practical, always striving to elevate a moment, even when it doesn’t need it.
Another strange thing is how none of her food-related posts ever show anyone enjoying the dish. There’s no image of a cake slice on a plate, no kid with frosting on their chin, no half-eaten piece suggesting it was actually consumed. It’s the same vibe as her occasional posts about her children — always framed just so, always polished, never candid. You’re left wondering what’s real and what’s just a well-managed image. The cake photo, like many of her curated moments, lacks the warmth and spontaneity that makes people connect with influencers or public figures in the first place.
If this was her attempt to seem relatable and down-to-earth, it’s done the opposite. Instead of showing someone comfortable and capable in her home kitchen, it presents a version of Meghan that’s overly calculated and out of touch. The photo feels like it came from a different era — not just because of the cake style, but because of the entire aesthetic. It’s as if she’s frozen in the Instagram era of a decade ago, when #homemade and #rustic were the height of digital charm. In 2025, that look has lost its luster, and instead of coming off as quaint or cozy, it feels forced and outdated.
If Meghan really wants to rebrand herself and stay relevant in the digital age, she might want to rethink her entire approach to content creation. Today’s audience craves sincerity, not a sepia-toned imitation of domestic bliss. Maybe it’s time to hire someone who understands the current landscape — someone who can craft posts that feel modern, engaging, and yes, actually authentic. Because right now, her online presence feels like it's built on mismatched aesthetics, old trends, and an underlying desperation to be seen as effortlessly perfect.
Ultimately, the cake saga is less about baking and more about branding. Meghan’s carefully curated image continues to raise eyebrows, not just because of the inconsistencies, but because it all feels so disconnected from reality. In trying to channel a homemaker goddess vibe, she’s ended up offering content that lacks both flavor and depth. Her attempts to position herself as a lifestyle icon are coming across as stiff, staged, and, frankly, a little embarrassing. It's not that people expect perfection — far from it. But they do expect honesty, and right now, all they're getting is a sugary facade.
Post a Comment